Moderately Reduced Carbohydrate Diet Could Help Weight Loss

According to researchers, a diet with a slight reduction from the American norm of calories from carbohydrates could help with weight loss.

“There has been great public interest in low-carbohydrate diets for weight loss, but they are difficult to maintain, in part because of the drastic reduction in carbohydrates,” said coauthor Barbara Gower.

Gower and her co-workers investigated whether a modest reduction in dietary carbohydrates, or “carbs,” would improve feelings of fullness better than a carbohydrate level comparable to that of the typical U.S. diet.

In a standard American diet, according to Gower, 55 percent of daily calories consumed come from carbohydrates: sugars, starches and fiber. The control diet used in their study contained 55 percent of daily calories from carbohydrates, in contrast to their “moderate-carb diet” which was 43 percent of calories from carbohydrates. The moderate-carb diet had more fat than their control diet, 39 percent versus 27 percent of calories, so that protein intake could be the same percentage. The researchers matched the protein intake of both diets studied (18 percent of calories) because protein may influence both satiety (“fullness”) and insulin secretion.

The researchers assigned the moderate-carb diet to 16 adults and the standard diet to 14 adults for a month. Subjects received enough calories to maintain their weight at what it was before the study. During the study they were weighed each weekday, and if a participant gained or lost weight, the amount of food was modified individually so weight could stay the same. After the subjects adjusted to their diet for 4 weeks, they ate a test meal, a breakfast that was specific to their diet.

When carbs are eaten and digested, they change into sugar. Before and after the meal, the researchers measured the subjects’ levels of insulin and circulating glucose (nonfasting blood sugar) and asked them to rate their hunger or fullness. They evaluated insulin response to a meal and blood sugar levels, because lower insulin and stable blood sugar levels may contribute to increased feelings of fullness, Gower explained.

“Subjects on the moderate carbohydrate diet had a smaller increase in insulin and thus a more stable glucose level,” said Gower. “They reported that they felt fuller for a longer period of time following the meal than did those with a diet more in line with what most Americans consume. Ultimately, this may help with weight loss because people may be less likely to overeat due to hunger pangs.”

Their research showed that, even in the absence of weight loss, a modest reduction in dietary carbohydrates was sufficient to lower insulin and stabilize blood sugar after a meal. Ratings of fullness were higher in the group on the moderate-carb diet before eating breakfast and stayed higher for a longer time after the meal, compared with those eating the standard diet.

“Over the long run a sustained modest reduction in carbohydrate intake may help to reduce energy consumption and facilitate weight loss,” Gower said.

Related Articles